Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I believe that technically, in English, "he" is the correct gender neutral pronoun. It just feels wrong so people commonly try to find other options.


It's been surprisingly fluid over the history of English. One interesting bit to read about is the history of "singular they", i.e. the use of "they" in sentences such as "if a person wishes to gain access, they must enter the code". This was fairly common in pre-19th-century English, then fell out of favor in the 19th and early 20th centuries as grammarians considered it incorrect ("they" was deemed solely a plural pronoun), and now it's making a comeback as a gender-neutral singular pronoun. The construction "he or she" also has usage going back centuries, as a different approach to that. And as you note, the use of "he" as a stand-in pronoun is also traditional, but falling a bit out of favor lately. Overall I don't think there is one correct answer for how English deals with that situation; it varies across writers and eras.


As _delirium said, the singular "they" has been making a comeback and will likely earn its place in academic writing in a generation.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: