Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Two sites with two different intentions. Hacker News is for reading interesting things and learning, StackOverflow is for getting answers to problems. I don't think SO would benefit from leaving popular non-constructive questions unlocked.


I read the thread on SO and I learned. If their end is to help users understand and learn via a question format, then isn't this question fitting?

I get what you are saying, but what if my problem is I'm having a hard time understanding vim fundamentals?

Perhaps "the problem" is subjective to begin with because it is relative to each of us.


I grok your thinking.

Some problems have subjective answers. They're still real problems. They still have real questions, and more than one answer can exist.


SO is for programming questions, though, and this isn't. There are better venues for it, like other SE sites.


where your question will also be locked...

oh- and in the interim, it will receive attention from but 1% of the qualified posters SO has.


where your question will also be locked...

Not if you choose the right venue. Now that I read the question, you're right that it'd probably be blocked on any SE site because it's a poor fit for their Q&A format, but SE is not the only programming community online.

oh- and in the interim, it will receive attention from but 1% of the qualified posters SO has.

So? Should I start posting the results of the UEFA Champions League here just because there are many interesting posters here?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: