If LFR were alive today (assuming* the underlying mechanism of war has not changed) perhaps he would take his argument online, in the hopes that people might be able to play with the data in his patiently gathered .xls files and decide for themselves?
Unfortunately, nothing tends to squick the Spiessbürger/petits bougies so quickly as sheets and peace.
pedantry: of course he can't recall, if he's querying for "this Roman general", as they were "these": Titus Veturius Calvinus ac Spurius Postumius Albinus Caudinus
>fourches caudines, Signori Quids
Poisson and peace-ing, both!
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_the_Caudine_Forks
> Its designation as a battle is a mere historical formality: there was no fighting and there were no casualties