Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> I linked a video

I've already rebutted your claims about this video multiple times. Your response has been to repeat the same assertions without even bothering to address my rebuttals.

> the reason I'm arguing with you is because you grossly misrepresent the late, great Dan Dennett

Apparently we're never going to agree on who is misrepresenting Dennett. But I'm curious: how much Dennett have you actually read?

> I'm trying to figure out A) Why you think this

Because, as I've already told you, I have read every book Dennett ever published on consciousness and free will, and a fair portion of his papers on those topics that never got put into one of his books, and based on all of that reading, I think you are misrepresenting Dennett's position. What's more, the counter arguments I see you giving are the same ones Dennett responded to for several decades. I see nothing new whatever in anything you've posted that would change my mind about who is misrepresenting what.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: