I see where we differ in opinion. I do believe that the human mind is just a very particular material arrangement. Therefore while different in scale to an LLM and likely also differing in structure, I do think both systems are fundamentally in the same category.
Given that, we could never agree. But that's fine.
Yes that is the key contention. I don't think that our minds are material, because if they were then we couldn't handle any immaterial concepts. Although obviously our brains are involved in the operation of the mind, they cannot be an exhaustive explanation of what the mind is, given that he mind is perfectly comfortable to leave the material world behind.
Given that, we could never agree. But that's fine.
And by the way, I actually hope you're right.