Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

My daily driver is over a decade old and has only ever entered a tire shop.

It was the first generation of EV.

When should I plan it's obsolescence?

What is your experience with EV expiration that leads you to your conclusion? Please inform me in any form other than links to idle speculation by obviously biased parties like Motor Trend etc.



Thanks for the feedback, thats great to hear.

I was referencing the battery production and lifetime. As well as the reasonable to expect overall lifetime and repair ability. How many decades do you expect to use it?

Given what goes into these batteries and the inability to recycle the components, sustainable is quite questionable. This is a stop gap that only solves a very specific metric, fossil fuels.

There is also an economic incentive to sell more stuff to a limited numbers of customers. Thats visible with most products, its just market forces so i dont expect EV to magically withstand that. We likely need actually more sustainable (as in designed for) but that goes counter to market forces.

edit: To give examples for the general trend, i have two saws from the same maker, the newer one with a difficult to replicate plastic clip holding the sawblade. Defect controller board for mid-bikes would officially mean replacing the motor. Printers and phones dont need to be mentioned. Given fiduciary responsibility to their shareholders you cant expect much else. New models are designed and need to be sold. Thats problematic given the materials used.


Jesus cool down. You know modern car production produces junk that mostly will fall apart in 10 years.

First generation of anything are overbuilt by modern mba product engineering practices. I have a 2011 Nissan Leaf that I hope to still be using in another 10 years.


How many miles are on it? City/hwy?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: