Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> How do we know it is a spy balloon and not just a weather balloon that got lost?

It has a much larger payload than weather balloons.

> If it is a spy balloon why not take it down gently and look at its payload?

That's what they did. Controlled shootdown over shallow water; they're collecting the parts now.

> Did the balloon got on top of a military base by chance or was it directed? How was it directed from so far away if the balloon has no propellers?

The Pentagon says it maneuvers. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/chinese-spy-ballo... Might be small propellers (think drone props) within that truss structure.



If we can launch wildly complex space hardware to look into the deepest regions of the universe we can bring down a balloon without the IronEagle dog fighter theatrics. You have to admit this came across like some old-timey George Creel propaganda.


We've plenty of reason to develop the technology for space flight.

We've essentially zero reason to develop the technology to hijack a high-altitude helium ballooon. As clearly demonstrated, much easier techniques already exist.


We spend decades and billiobs if dollars planning and building space telescopes.

Why would we spend money investing in a balloon defense system, when we already have an air defense system that can handle them.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: