Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Is the US failing at math and science? I don't take a metric like test scores or diplomas at face value. Maybe I could entertain international patents granted, but not without some more detailed analysis.

I don't think I've ever seen a proper analysis of the question of whether the US really is all that poor on math and science.

I think the huge US military industrial complex may play a big role in confusing the issue. An enormous amount of US scientific prowess is busy serving the pentagon. The casual observer sees the technological output of, say, Japan more readily because it's in consumer goods.



Related to this, when we talk about a nation falling behind in math and science, what we actually care about is applied math and science (technology innovation) and how it affects economic competitiveness. A nation of Grothendiecks, Erdoses and Perelemans would not be a huge player in the world economy.

What these metrics don't measure is that a lot of people who create important technology advances and businesses are dropouts, misfits, guys who did bad on their exams and people from completely different fields.


...a nation of Grothendiecks, Erdoses and Perelemans...

mmm




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: