Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> If my mother is no longer competent to reason on her own, it is my responsibility as the eldest male in the family to take responsibility. Is it not?

Believing this particular set of lies is not, however, a reliable market for mental competence. You yourself note how widespread these ideas are among your family, most of whom are presumptively mentally competent adults.

Any chain of reasoning that leads to a conclusion like "half of the country is mentally incompetent" should be suspect.

In a way, this whole situation is where a whole suite of ideas like postmodernism, epistemological/cultural/moral relativism etc., come home to roost. After all, these are just alternative facts, and what we hear from so-called experts is just, like, their opinion, man.



I never claimed that.

What I'm saying is: my mother's wellbeing will soon be my direct responsibility.

Obviously I'd rather have my mom take care of herself... Less work for me. But her ability to handle money has appreciably degenerated, and now this COVID thing is proving to me that she is unable to fully analyze the news on her own.


What I am saying is that since mentally competent adults also believe these lies, you mustn't use that belief as evidence one way or another.

Doing so is basically falling victim to confirmation bias.

I suggest you try to base your decision on other evidence (such as the ability to handle money you mentioned) only.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: